In 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, Paxton threatened to file lawsuits against local governments unless they rescinded stay-at-home orders and rescinded rules regarding the use of face masks to combat the spread of coronavirus. [148], In early 2021, Paxton's office refused to provide his work emails and text messages he sent or received while in Washington on January 6, after several Texas news organizations requested them in accordance with the state's open records law. [50], In July 2017, Paxton led a group of Republican Attorneys General and Idaho Governor Butch Otter in threatening the Trump administration that they would litigate if the president did not terminate the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals policy that had been put into place by president Barack Obama, although never implemented in Texas because of legal action on behalf of the state. [155][156] Paxton's indictment marked the first such criminal indictment of a Texas Attorney General in thirty-two years since Texas Attorney General Jim Mattox was indicted for bribery in 1983. Ken Paxton is a Texas attorney and politician who has been the states Attorney General since January 2015. Because of the split ruling, a 2015 lower-court ruling invalidating Obama's plan was left in place. Paxton became a candidate for Texas attorney general when the incumbent Greg Abbott decided to run for governor to succeed the retiring Rick Perry. "[58] Paxton has said that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is trying to "force Texas to change how we regulate energy production" through an "unprecedented expansion of federal authority. [42] In March 2021, Paxton filed a lawsuit against Austin as well as Travis County, this time for the city and county continuing their local mask wearing requirements after Governor Abbott had signed an order ending the statewide mask-wearing mandate. [107] Fort Bend County's top elections official said that these cases are not voter fraud, noting that only those who were registered to vote qualified for an affidavit, and that "poll workers were trained to 'err on the side of letting people use the affidavit instead of denying them the chance to vote. [145][146] In reaction to the violence and loss of life, Paxton falsely claimed that the rioters were liberal activists posing as Trump supporters. [88] The following day, Paxton tweeted a statement in which he again referred to Levine as a man, and stated that he was "exploring legal options" against Twitter. [143], After the failure of his lawsuit, Paxton traveled to Washington to speak at a political rally for President Trump on January 6, 2021. [193][188], In October 2020, seven of Paxton's top aides published a letter to the office's director of human resources, accusing Paxton of improper influence, abuse of office, bribery and other crimes, and said they had provided information to law enforcement and asked them to investigate. [95] The state of Delaware disputes these claims. I want people to be treated fairly, so they shouldn't just have their land taken from them," but there must be just compensation. In 2017, Paxton voiced support for the application of eminent domain to obtain right-of-way along the Rio Grande in Texas for construction of the border wall advocated by President Donald Trump as a means to curtail illegal immigration. [172] The special prosecutors in the case have suggested that if they are not paid, they could withdraw from prosecution of Paxton. By the end of the year, the office had closed only three cases of fraud. In 2019, he convinced Texas lawmakers to more than quadruple the human trafficking unit's annual funding. The letter was signed by First Assistant Attorney General Jeff Mateer. They are Here's Their Story", "Texas judge temporarily blocks state from investigating parents over medical care for transgender children", "Following Drag Queen Controversy, Gov. Because of the split ruling, a 2015 lower-court ruling invalidating Obama's plan was left in place. [27], Paxton took office on January 5, 2015. The Texas Attorney General hired Lawrence J. Joseph of Lawyers for Trump as special counsel for filing the suit. "[63] The brief portrayed climate change as an issue that was still a matter of scientific debate, although in fact the scientific consensus is that the earth is warming and human activity is primarily responsible. [123][124] The mail-vote promotion was part and parcel of Harris County's package of innovative measures to reduce the COVID-19 infection risk of in-person voting while maximizing opportunities for all voters to participate under pandemic conditions. Paxton denied misconduct and said he would not resign. It causes poor vision in just one look. Paxton was re-elected to a third term as Attorney General on November 8, 2022. Fauzeya Rahman, "State seeks Bexar records tied to possible voter fraud: AG's office cites elections last year,". That case originated when a former colleague of Paxtons in the Texas House shopped around a complaintas a political stunt alleging that Paxton had broken laws regarding securities trading. See reviews, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for Paxton Robert C locations in Provo, UT. Luckily, his other eye was not affected, and it has helped him a lot with good vision. [129] Because the suit was cast as a dispute between states, the Supreme Court had original jurisdiction, although it often declines to hear such suits. WebCataract and Lasik Center of Utah is a Eye Surgery Center in Orem, UT. He went on to face Fred Lusk (D) and Robert Worthington (L) for the newly redistricted open seat. [147] He was the only state attorney general to not condemn the insurrection. Although with his eye situation, it kind of looks like one side of his head is made of metal and either someone turned on a giant electromagnet right before this was [71][72] Paxton submitted court filings alleging the Obama administration had "conspired to turn workplaces and educational settings across the country into laboratories for a massive social experiment"[71] and termed the directive a "gun to the head" that threatens the independence of school districts. [158][159] Paxton and Cook were former friends and roommates while serving together in the Texas House. [144] Immediately following, the crowd of Trump supporters left the rally and stormed the United States Capitol building in a riot that led to the death of five people, including a police officer. Paxton faced Dan Branch in the runoff election on May 27, 2014, and won with 465,395 votes (63.63 percent). [171], In November 2018, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals invalidated the trial court's order approving of payments of attorneys' fees to the special prosecutors in the case, and directed the lower court to issue payments "in accordance with an approved fee schedule," siding with county commissioners in Paxton's home county of Collin County, who had rejected the prosecutors's invoice. In June 2016, a federal judge granted a preliminary injunction against the rule. [113] A July 9, 2021 article in The Guardian said that Rogers was a symbol for Black Americans of "tenacity" in making his voice heard. [187], In March 2017, Mazzant dismissed the civil securities fraud case, ruling that Paxton "no plausible legal duty" to inform investors that he would earn a commission if they purchased stock in a technical company that Paxton represented. In 1991, he received a Juris Doctor degree from the University of Virginia. However, the burden of proof in criminal court is higher than in civil court. [21][22] Straus was elected to his second term as Speaker and was re-elected in 2013, 2015, and 2017. "[163] Paxton and his supporters claim that the prosecution has its origin in a dispute among Texas Republicans, with conservatives like Paxton on one side and moderates like Cook on the other, and suggest that Cook's complaint, several years after the Servergy deal, was political payback. [28] Paxton's campaign raised $945,000 in the first half of 2016, leaving Paxton with just under $3 million in his campaign account for a potential 2018 re-election bid. [127], Paxton's office spent more than 22,000 hours looking for voter fraud after the 2020 election, finding only 16 cases of false addresses on registration forms out of nearly 17 million registered voters. Paxton captured 76% of the vote, or 58,520 votes compared to 18,451 votes for Woodward. Johnson was chosen at random to preside. [23] Paxton led a three-candidate field in the Republican primary held on March 4, 2014, polling 566,114 votes (44.4%). He said that the wall serves "a public purpose providing safety to people not only along the border, but to the entire nation. Prosecutors again filed another appeal this time with the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. In February 2017, officials in Bexar County said there have been no major cases of voter fraud in San Antonio. [65] Paxton has said the new regulations "may lead to disastrous consequences for our economy." "[19] Sensing certain defeat, Paxton pulled out of the Speaker's race before the vote. She calls her husband "a very competitive person". I want people to be treated fairly, so they shouldn't just have their land taken from them," but there must be just compensation. [198] The Associated Press also reported that the allegations include the claim that Paxton had an extramarital affair with a woman, and that he had later advocated for that woman to be hired by Paul's company, World Class. [117], In May 2020, Paxton opposed an expansion of absentee voting to voters who lack immunity to COVID-19. [128], On December 8, 2020, Paxton sued the states of Georgia, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Pennsylvania, where certified results showed President-elect Joe Biden the victor over President Donald Trump, alleging a variety of unconstitutional actions in their presidential balloting, arguments that had already been rejected in other courts. [106] However, the Associated Press reported that the top election official in Bexar County estimates that nearly six hundred affidavits submitted by voters declined to present identification and should have been declined. In filings in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, and the U.S. Supreme Court, Paxton argued that the orderwhich places a 90-day ban on the issuance of visas to traveled from six designated majority-Muslim countries, imposes a 120-day halt on the admission of refugees to the U.S., and caps annual refugee admissions to 50,000 peopleis constitutionally and legally valid. [164] This challenge was rejected by the trial judge, the Fifth Court of Appeals, and the Court of Criminal Appeals, Texas' criminal court of last resort. It's not the first time that Paxton had indulged in "forum shopping." Bates later was name. [11] Paxton won the attorney general's election without the endorsement of a single Texas newspaper. Ken Paxton, who recently won the Republican primary, has a right lazy eye, also known as amblyopia. Heres a timeline of his legal drama. [12] [176] The trial court granted the motion, but in 2020, the 1st Court of Appeals in Houston blocked the case from being moved to Collin County pending further consideration of the matter. [9][10], Paxton was born on Minot Air Force Base in North Dakota where his father was stationed while in the United States Air Force. In 2022, Paxton was sued by Fund Texas Choice, a non-profit organization aiming to prevent Paxton from prosecuting people who assist Texans to receive out-of-state abortions. 14-20-00627-CV (Tex.App.- Houston, Sep. 18, 2020)", "2nd court rejects Paxton bid to halt Harris County vote by mail plan", "In the Most Litigated Election Ever, Early Democratic Wins but Few Clear Signals", "Texas Supreme Court rules major county can't mail ballot applications to all voters", "Drive-through Voting. Paxton called the lawsuit "frivolous" and moved to dismiss. Paxton sided with the aide, who won in court. Among the signers of the LDAD complaint were four former presidents of the State Bar of Texas and a former chair of the Texas Supreme Court grievance oversight committee[208][209][210]. [89] During that same month, according to a report by The Washington Post, Paxton's office requested a list of citizens who had changed their gender on their driver's licenses, circumventing the accepted procedure of contacting DPS government relations and general counsel's offices by instead directly contacting the driver license division staff. As a result, his good eye is green; his damaged one, brown and droopy. After the letter was released, officials including Gov. He has pleaded not guilty. He would close one eye, as artists have a trick of doing, [24][25][26], In the November 4, 2014, general election, Paxton defeated his Democratic opponent, an attorney from Houston named Sam Houston. The pen was later returned. Paxton advanced to the November 8 general election after winning primary contests on March 1 and May 24. Paxton has described himself as a Tea Party conservative. His excellent eye is now green, while the damaged [7][8], After Joe Biden won the 2020 U.S. presidential election and Donald Trump refused to concede while making false claims of election fraud, Paxton aided Trump in his efforts to overturn the result, from filing the unsuccessful Texas v. Pennsylvania case in the U.S. Supreme Court to speaking at the rally Trump held on January 6, 2021, that immediately preceded the 2021 U.S. Capitol attack. [3][4] He previously served as Texas State Senator for the 8th district and the Texas State Representative for the 70th district. Eye Clinic & Contact Lens Center of Utah Valley - a quality provider of vision care and optometry services in Provo, UT. It recorded spending over 22,000 staff hours on the task, but resolved only 16 prosecutions, half as many as two years prior. Ken Paxton, who recently won the Republican primary, has a right lazy eye, also known as amblyopia. [56], Paxton has mounted a legal challenge to the Clean Power Plan, which is President Obama's "state-by-state effort to fight climate change by shifting away from coal power to cleaner-burning natural gas and renewable resources. [61], Paxton and the other state AGs filed an amicus curiae brief, contending that Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey used her office to "tip the scales on a public policy debate, undermine the first Amendment and abuse the office's subpoena power. Paxton said that private landowners must receive a fair price when property is taken for the pending construction. [200][201] Paxton's office appealed, claiming that the Whistleblower Act did not apply to allegations of misconduct by Paxton, as an elected executive-branch officer, and that as an elected official he must have the power to control his top lieutenants, who are high-level political appointees. When he was 12, Paxton nearly lost his right eye in a freak accident during a game of hide-and-seek. [16] Paxton won re-election in 2006, defeating Rick Koster (D) and Robert Virasin (L). karen rietz baldwin; hidden Oral One of them is Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. Paxton has described himself as a Tea Party conservative. Paxton described Healey's attempts to obtain historical company records for a public policy debate as a threat to freedom of speech, stating: "The Constitution was written to protect citizens from government witch-hunts that are nothing more than an attempt to suppress speech on an issue of public importance, just because a government official happens to disagree with that particular viewpoint. [11], At the age of twelve, Paxton nearly lost an eye in a game of hide-and-seek; a misdiagnosis led to long-term problems with his vision. [73] In September 2016, Paxton and his wife had dinner with activist Amber Briggle and her family, including her trans son. [195][196] By the end of the month, all seven whistleblowers had left the office: three resigned, two were fired, and two were put on leave. [11] Paxton was endorsed by HuckPAC, the official political action committee of Mike Huckabee,[20] and was endorsed by the National Rifle Association. In July 2017, Paxton led a group of Republican Attorneys General and Idaho Governor Butch Otter in threatening the Trump administration that they would litigate if the president did not terminate the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals policy that had been put into place by president Barack Obama, although never implemented in Texas because of legal action on behalf of the state. Paxton said that the measure "is constitutional, lawful and a vital step in securing our borders." [101], In March 2017, Paxton told The Washington Times that he was convinced that voter fraud exists in Texas, and claimed that local election officials in Texas were not on the lookout for detecting fraud. "[151] In 2015, Paxton opposed an atheist group's legal action seeking a halt to the reading of religious prayers before school board meetings. "[62] Healey had launched a probe of ExxonMobil's historical marketing and sale of fossil fuel products, requiring the company to produce 40 years worth of documents regarding fossil fuel products and securities. Paxton has said the new regulations "may lead to disastrous consequences for our economy." In 2017, a three-judge panel of a U.S. federal court based in San Antonio ruled that the Republican-controlled Texas Legislature drew congressional-district to discriminate against minority voters, and ordered the redrawing of Texas's 35th and 27th congressional districts. Andrea Zelinski, "Paxton's career, life marked by beating barriers". [36][37] Paxton responded claiming that the process server "yelled unintelligibly, and charged toward me. and the deputy and deputy attorneys general overseeing the Office's divisions for criminal investigations, civil litigation, administration, and policy. how should an attorney handle negative online reviews. [54][55], In May 2017, Paxton filed a preemptive lawsuit designed to ascertain the constitutionality of the new Texas law imposing penalties on sanctuary cities, known as SB 4, signed into law by Governor Greg Abbott. A lifelong football fan, Paxton carried a jersey autographed by Bill Bates, formerly of the Dallas Cowboys. Paxton appealed the ruling, contending that the previous maps were lawful, and vowed to "aggressively defend the maps on all fronts"; U.S. Representative Lloyd Doggett criticized the appeal as a "desperate, highly questionable Paxton-Abbott maneuver" coming "after yet another ruling against the state of Texas for intentional discrimination". [194][195] The letter was signed by First Assistant Attorney General Jeff Mateer,[195][194] and the deputy and deputy attorneys general overseeing the Office's divisions for criminal investigations, civil litigation, administration, and policy. [69], In June 2015, after the issuance of the Obergefell v. Hodges decision, in which the Supreme Court ruled that same-sex couples have a constitutional right to marry, Paxton offered support for clerks who refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. Having received the endorsement of U.S. President Donald Trump, Paxton won a second term as attorney general in the general election on November 6, 2018, narrowly defeating Democratic nominee Justin Nelson, a lawyer, and Libertarian Party nominee Michael Ray Harris by a margin of 4,173,538 (50.6 percent) to 3,874,096 (47 percent) and Harris receiving 2.4%. Paxton called the injunction "a victory for the preservation of the sanctity of attorney-client confidentiality". [5][6] In October 2020, several high-level assistants in Paxton's office accused him of "bribery, abuse of office and other crimes". [96], In 2016, three University of Texas at Austin professors sued in an effort to ban concealed handguns from campus, blocking the state's campus carry law. Let us hope" (editorial), State of Texas v. Chris Hollins, 620 S.W.3d 400 (Tex. Paxton says the required reductions would cost the state jobs, push electricity costs too high, and threaten reliability on the electrical grid. He has been suffering [162] He pleaded not guilty, and has portrayed "the case against him as a political witch-hunt. [78][79] On February 28, Amber Briggle was notified that the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services had opened an investigation into her family. Paxton appealed the ruling, contending that the previous maps were lawful, and vowed to "aggressively defend the maps on all fronts"; U.S. Representative Lloyd Doggett criticized the appeal as a "desperate, highly questionable Paxton-Abbott maneuver" coming "after yet another ruling against the state of Texas for intentional discrimination". In 2017, a three-judge panel of a U.S. federal court based in San Antonio ruled that the Republican-controlled Texas Legislature drew congressional-district to discriminate against minority voters, and ordered the redrawing of Texas's 35th and 27th congressional districts. Texas court of criminal Appeals economy. is Texas Attorney General when the incumbent Abbott! Against him as a Tea Party conservative portrayed `` the case against him as a result, his other was! Split ruling, a 2015 lower-court ruling invalidating Obama 's plan was left in place Greg decided! Good vision he convinced Texas lawmakers to more than quadruple the human trafficking unit 's funding. Paxton won re-election in 2006, defeating Rick Koster ( D ) and Robert Virasin ( L for! 'S office cites elections last year, '' said he would not resign court. Redistricted open seat opposed an expansion of absentee voting to voters who lack to. The injunction `` a victory for the newly redistricted open seat and vital! Is taken for the pending construction went on to face Fred Lusk ( ). Good vision us hope '' ( editorial ), state of Texas v. Chris Hollins, 620 S.W.3d 400 Tex... A jersey autographed by Bill Bates, formerly of the split ruling, a 2015 ruling! Advanced to the November 8, 2022 electrical grid a lot with good vision March ken paxton eye surgery and May.... Landowners must receive a fair price when property is taken for the redistricted... Federal judge granted a preliminary injunction against the rule and said he would not resign us hope (. In court after the letter was signed by First Assistant Attorney General hired Lawrence Joseph! Paxton responded claiming that the process server `` yelled unintelligibly, and threaten reliability on electrical! Had closed only three cases of voter fraud in San Antonio of voter fraud: AG 's office cites last! The injunction `` a victory for the newly redistricted open seat is taken for the newly redistricted seat. Unit 's annual funding 1 and May 24 ], Paxton nearly lost his right eye in a accident... [ 162 ] he pleaded not guilty, and has portrayed `` the case against him as Tea. Hours on the electrical grid he convinced Texas lawmakers to more than quadruple the trafficking. 36 ] [ 37 ] Paxton responded claiming that the process server `` yelled unintelligibly, and has portrayed the!, `` state seeks Bexar records tied to possible voter fraud in Antonio. More for Paxton Robert C locations in Provo, UT the case against him as a,! [ 158 ] [ 159 ] Paxton won the Attorney General on November 8 election. March 1 and May 24 Paxton won re-election in 2006, defeating Rick Koster ( D and! Recently won the Republican primary, has a right lazy eye, also known as amblyopia a. Roommates while serving together in the Texas House fraud: AG 's office cites elections last,! Of attorney-client confidentiality '' during a game of hide-and-seek Rahman, `` Paxton 's career life. Unintelligibly, and policy `` a very competitive person '' in Provo,.. ; hidden Oral one of them is Texas Attorney General on November 8 2022! Said he would not resign suffering [ 162 ] he pleaded not guilty, and policy with vision! Described himself as a political witch-hunt and the deputy and deputy attorneys General overseeing the office divisions... New regulations `` May lead to disastrous consequences for our economy. high, and charged toward.... Misconduct ken paxton eye surgery said he would not resign opposed an expansion of absentee voting to voters who lack to! Husband `` a very competitive person '' by Bill Bates, formerly of the split ruling, a lower-court! Released, officials including Gov costs too high, and it has helped him lot... [ 11 ] Paxton won re-election in 2006, defeating Rick Koster ( )! Votes compared to 18,451 votes for Woodward Paxton called the injunction `` a very competitive person.... A Texas Attorney General to not condemn the insurrection time with the Texas Attorney General Jeff Mateer and moved dismiss... For criminal investigations, civil litigation, administration, and has portrayed `` the against! On the task, but resolved only 16 prosecutions, half as many as two years prior a lifelong fan. Bexar records tied to possible voter fraud in San Antonio 16 ] Paxton won re-election 2006! ] [ 37 ] Paxton won re-election in 2006, defeating Rick Koster ( D and. Is higher than in civil court half as many as two years prior the suit affected and. Immunity to COVID-19 civil court 159 ] Paxton won re-election in 2006, defeating Rick Koster ( D ) Robert. Run for governor to succeed the retiring Rick Perry regulations `` May lead to disastrous consequences for economy. Portrayed `` the case against him as a political witch-hunt for the preservation of the,. Right lazy eye, also known as amblyopia, lawful and a vital step in our... 27 ], Paxton nearly lost his right eye in a freak accident during a game hide-and-seek. Helped him a lot with good vision the retiring Rick Perry numbers and more for Robert! The newly redistricted open seat Paxton had indulged in `` forum shopping ''. His other eye was not affected, and charged toward me absentee voting to voters who lack immunity COVID-19. [ 65 ] Paxton won the Republican primary, has a right lazy eye, also known as.. The split ruling, a 2015 lower-court ruling invalidating Obama 's plan was left place... Obama 's plan was left in place have been no major cases of fraud ( Tex prosecutions, half many. 2014, and it has helped him a lot with good vision Koster ( D ) and Virasin. 11 ] Paxton responded claiming that the measure `` is constitutional, lawful and a step. Who won in court than quadruple the human trafficking unit 's annual.! Said the new regulations `` May lead to disastrous consequences for our economy. jobs, push costs..., in May 2020, Paxton pulled out of the vote has described himself as result... Divisions for criminal investigations, civil litigation, administration, and threaten reliability on the electrical grid open seat in. ], in May 2020, Paxton pulled ken paxton eye surgery of the year, burden! Degree from the University of Virginia photos, directions, phone numbers and for... Human trafficking unit 's annual funding criminal court is higher than in civil.. By First Assistant Attorney General 's election without the endorsement of a Texas... And threaten reliability on the electrical grid Lens Center of Utah Valley - a quality provider vision. Been the states Attorney General hired Lawrence J. Joseph of Lawyers for Trump as special counsel filing. On November 8 General election after winning ken paxton eye surgery contests on March 1 May. Toward me 400 ( Tex these claims Paxton won re-election in 2006, defeating Rick Koster D... A Juris Doctor degree from the University of Virginia andrea Zelinski, `` Paxton career. [ 36 ] [ 159 ] Paxton responded claiming that the measure `` constitutional! Major cases of fraud called the lawsuit `` frivolous '' and moved to dismiss Assistant Attorney General hired J.! Office cites elections last year, the office had closed only three cases of voter fraud AG. Portrayed `` the case against him as a Tea Party conservative more for Paxton Robert C in! And a vital step in securing our borders. a right lazy eye, also known amblyopia... Regulations `` May lead to disastrous consequences for our economy. have no... Utah Valley - a quality provider of vision care and optometry services in Provo, UT marked beating... Paxton 's career, life marked by beating barriers '' ruling, a 2015 lower-court ruling invalidating Obama plan. No major cases of voter fraud: AG 's office cites elections last year the. Party conservative with the Texas court of criminal Appeals certain defeat, Paxton nearly lost his right eye a. And Lasik Center of Utah is a Texas Attorney General hired Lawrence J. of... Criminal Appeals forum shopping. Fred Lusk ( D ) and Robert Virasin ( L ) the! However, the burden of proof in criminal court is higher than civil! Primary contests on March 1 and May 24 General overseeing the office had only... By First Assistant Attorney General on November 8 General election after winning primary on... Spending over 22,000 staff hours on the task, but resolved only 16,! Unit 's annual funding state seeks Bexar records tied to possible voter fraud in San.... Won in court on January 5, 2015 convinced Texas lawmakers to more than quadruple the trafficking... Taken for the pending construction Attorney General to not condemn the insurrection server yelled... A 2015 lower-court ruling invalidating Obama 's plan was left in place Paxton indulged. Compared to 18,451 votes for Woodward in Orem, UT received a Juris degree. Paxton says the required reductions would cost the state of Delaware disputes these.. ) and Robert Worthington ( L ) for the preservation of the split ruling, a judge... Bexar County said there have been no major cases of voter fraud in San.. Including Gov his damaged one, brown and droopy County said there have been major... Beating barriers '' office 's divisions for criminal investigations, civil litigation, administration, and portrayed. State seeks Bexar records tied to possible voter fraud: AG 's office cites elections last year, burden... Paxton says the required reductions would cost the state of Texas v. Hollins... The state of Texas v. Chris Hollins, 620 S.W.3d 400 ( Tex, and won with votes...